Let’s start by killing the myth.
There’s no single, flawless ad waiting to be born. No silver bullet. No one-line miracle that works for everyone, every time. And chasing that illusion? It’s a great way to waste time, burn budget and stall performance.
Now—what counts as “better-performing” depends on your goals. There’s no universal metric, but for most performance marketers, it comes down to one thing: ROAS.
The ad that wins is the ad that works. Period. Real creative success isn’t just about taps or traffic. It’s about turning that traffic into outcomes that move the business.
Test, test, test!
-
-
- Start with high-traffic, low-revenue placements to minimize risk and maximize data volume.
- A/B test single variables when you’re narrowing in. Use multivariate tests when you want to explore combinations.
- Track patterns across winning creatives. Is urgency converting better? Humor? Contrasting colors? Emotional payoff
-
Let the data be your gut check.
So why do high-potential ads get killed in review? Bias. We’re quick to reject work that feels too loud, too risky or too off-brand.
But here’s the thing: users don’t see your internal mood boards or brand decks. They see a message. And the ad that feels a little uncomfortable in a meeting often ends up being the one that stops the scroll and drives action.
Use your gut to generate ideas—but let the data decide what stays in rotation. Go in with a hypothesis: Why do you think this version will work? Then track the metrics that will prove (or disprove) it. That’s how you challenge assumptions—and uncover creative that truly connects.
Treat every test as a learning lab.
You didn’t “lose” if a variation underperforms. You learned.
Underperformers can reveal where your message broke down: weak tone, unclear hierarchy, bad timing, wrong emotional trigger… If you document those outcomes, you build a reference library of what not to repeat.
Create a simple system—a learnings doc or spreadsheet works great—and track what underperformed (and why). Was the CTA too soft? Was the visual too cluttered? Was the concept too clever?
Over time, those insights add up. They sharpen your instincts and accelerate your iteration cycles. In the best setups, testing isn’t just your gatekeeper—it’s your teacher.
FINAL THOUGHT
Great ideas don’t win. Great outcomes do.
Testing isn’t the end of creativity—it’s what unlocks it.
Build ads that can adapt, improve and deliver. Then do it again.
We’ll keep diving into that process—how to test smarter, iterate faster and scale what works—in future Signal + Story posts.
Stay tuned.
Never Miss a Drop.
ARTICLE
ARTICLE
ARTICLE
INTERVIEW
DTC Creative Leader